6 Nations
Injuries Pile Up, but Who Should Start for Ireland?
After Ireland’s defeat to England questions have been raised so who should be given a chance to play in Murrayfield?
With the loss to England fresh in the mind Ireland must move on quickly and pick themselves up before facing Scotland in Murrayfield on Saturday.
The thing on everyone’s mind is who will Joe Schmidt pick in his matchday 23 to bounce back.
It has been confirmed that Garry Ringrose, Devin Toner and CJ Stander will play no part against the Scots after picking up injuries which could force Schmidt’s selection slightly.
Update: @Ringrose_G & @DevinToner4 have been ruled out for the game against Scotland.@KEITHEARLS87 trained today.
— Irish Rugby (@IrishRugby) February 5, 2019
The main criticism that the team has faced in the aftermath of their defeat was their lack of intensity throughout the game. So, who could bring that up, who could kick start their championship?
To start with, the front-row. The pack was inferior to the English last weekend, but the front-rowers are unlikely to change with most expecting Cian Healy, captain Rory Best, and Tadhg Furlong to retain their places.
They had a bad day at the office, however it would be hard to see any of them getting dropped.
In the locks James Ryan is almost certain to continue in the team, the question is who will partner him? It’s between last week’s sub Quinn Roux, Ultan Dillane, and newly drafted in Billy Holland after Toner was ruled out.
Roux has been a regular on the bench over the past while under Schmidt so he would appear the most likely to come into the starting XV, with Dillane or Holland on the bench.
The back-row is another area where a change is certain after it was confirmed CJ Stander played 62 minutes against England with two fractures in his cheek and eye socket. An injury which leaves him out for a minimum of four weeks.
Not the result we wanted but an incredible experience nonetheless and proud of @CJStander playing 62 mins with two fractures in his cheek and eye socket ? pic.twitter.com/GUswqOO8QJ
— Ryk Neethling (@RykNeethling) February 2, 2019
The options at No 8 would probably be Jack Conin, an out and out eight, or the highly versatile Sean O’Brien. Rhys Ruddock and Jordi Murphy are other options, but what would seem clear is that whoever is picked will play with Peter O’Mahony and Josh Van Der Flier.
O’Mahony’s position is never really under question when he is fit as his leadership and work rate would see him into nearly any team. Van Der Flier has surely cemented his place in the side for at least this match after an outstanding showing in defeat, in which he made a sensational 19 tackles.
No 6 O’Mahony believes Leinster man O’Brien should start, but admits that he doesn’t pick the team, it’s only his opinion.
“I’m not going to sit here and pick the team, but Sean O’Brien, the name along speaks for itself,” he said when speaking about the weekend.
“He’s been unlucky with injury here and there, but there isn’t anybody more professional and a big-game player than Sean O’Brien,” he added showing his support for O’Brien’s inclusion.
Elsewhere, the half-backs are pretty set in stone with Conor Murray and Johnny Sexton expected to continue at scrum-half and out-half respectively.
Joey Carbery could be a surprise inclusion if there is any doubt over Sexton but is more likely to remain on the bench.
Bundee Aki will probably be at 12, and after his stint at full-back, Robbie Henshaw is almost certain to come in at 13 for the injured Garry Ringrose.
Chris Farrell is another option, along with utility back Will Addison if Schmidt wants to switch things up.
Henshaw’s move from 15 will mean changes to the back three too.
Last year’s player of the championship, Jacob Stockdale, has to stay at 11 after he still managed to make 78 metres last weekend with hardly any ball in hand.
Keith Earls trained well earlier today but was unconvincing against England before his withdrawal at half-time. That could open up the door for the likes of Jordan Larmour or Will Addison to sneak onto that wing, but probably not.
Andrew Conway would have been an option but has returned to Munster following an injury and is unavailable.
Rob Kearney is the most obvious choice to replace Henshaw at full-back after being left out last weekend. It is an opportunity he would relish to show his worth to the team.
Larmour and Addison could also be considered, however Kearney would be the most reliable selection. Whoever is picked will have to be up for a lot of running with Scotland’s Stuart Hogg on top form at the moment.
Outside the starting team, the bench is as competitive.
Sean Cronin is most likely to be at 16 while Jack McGrath and Dave Kilcoyne will both be options at 17, and Andrew Porter probably at 18.
Whoever misses out between Roux, Dillane, and Holland in the battle to partner Ryan in the second-row will have to fight for a place on the bench too.
Holland being drafted into the squad would suggest he will probably be an impact sub to come in after the hour mark.
Again, the losers of the war in the back-row between Murphy, O’Brien, Ruddock and Conan will have to compete to be in the 23.
John Cooney is certain to be on the bench after his brilliant cameo last weekend when he scored a try and impressed with his quick hands.
Carbery will have to be in the squad with his quality, so if not in the first 15 he will be the 22nd man.
Larmour and Addison will be the three that will be trying to force their way into the 23.
The changes will bring new dimensions, but the team as a whole will need to bring their A-game to win back the fans and send a message out that they are still in the running for the World Cup.
No place is certain following last weekend’s defeat and with the likes of Dan Leavy, Tadhg Beirne, Luke McGrath, and so on to also come back from injury before Japan. This is not only a chance to get back in
Related Articles:
6 Nations
‘Everyone Showed Up Really Well’ – Easterby On Emerging Ireland’s Tour Opener
Despite their short preparation time together, and the fact that their opponents were coming off a 10-game Currie Cup season, Emerging Ireland tallied up six tries to secure a 36-24 win at Toyota Stadium in Bloemfontein.
Ireland Sevens Olympian Zac Ward burst past three defenders for the 14th-minute opener, and a closing penalty try was preceded by scores from Darragh Murray, Cormac Izuchukwu, Stephen Smyth, and replacement Gus McCarthy.
“The Pumas had a Currie Cup campaign to prepare for this game and we’ve had six or seven days but I think, to a man, our guys stepped up to the challenge,” said Easterby afterwards.
“I think these tours are always going to be challenging, they’re always going to put us under pressure for the time, but we certainly wouldn’t look for any excuses in terms of our preparation.
“I thought, on the whole, we were outstanding and everyone showed up really well. We got good minutes out of those guys that started, and we got a really good hit out of the guys who came off the bench and they added as well.”
All 23 players got time on the pitch, with only Ulster forward Izuchukwu and Leinster’s James Culhane, who stood out at number 8, having previously played for Emerging Ireland. They were both part of the 2022 tour to South Africa.
Six members of last season’s Ireland Under-20 squad made their Emerging Ireland debuts, including Smyth, Ben O’Connor, and Hugh Gavin as starters. They are all hoping this can be a launchpad towards playing Test rugby.
Of the Bloemfontein bunch from two years ago, six players have since graduated to win Ireland senior caps. The most notable are Jack Crowley, Joe McCarthy, and Calvin Nash, who have been regular starters this year for the back-to-back Guinness Men’s Six Nations champions.
Naas man Jamie Osborne shone during Ireland’s drawn summer series with South Africa, winning his first two caps at full-back, while Ciarán Frawley, who missed out on playing for Emerging Ireland in 2022 due to a shoulder injury, was the late drop goal hero in the second Test against the Springboks.
Speaking about how beneficial an Emerging Ireland tour is from both a playing and coaching perspective, Easterby noted: “Recent history shows that players who have been on this tour have kicked on. That’s part of the plan for this tour, to get guys to understand how we do things.
“There’s lots of great connectivity between the provinces and what they do and what we do. For us as coaches, to get to work with these players individually and as a group, but also they’re seeing the last two years, those guys who have gone on and got capped.
“I guess the challenge for the players on this tour is to make it as hard for us not to pick them over the next six to 12 months, going through to another World Cup cycle.
“So, I think there is that feel that there is genuine opportunity, and the reality is six guys have been capped and 48 caps have been gained by those six guys. The reality is there is a genuine pathway towards playing senior international rugby.”
Easterby and his fellow senior national coaches, Paul O’Connell, Andrew Goodman, and John Fogarty, brought a 33-strong squad with them to South Africa, and the ten players watching on from the stands today will be itching to line out against Western Force on Sunday afternoon.
With the Toyota Challenge clash with the Toyota Cheetahs next Wednesday completing the short three-match series, the tight turnarounds will certainly keep all involved, including the medical and S&C staff, on their toes.
Asked about any injuries coming out of the tour opener, the former Ireland and British & Irish Lions flanker replied: “I think Mark Donnelly, at the moment, has ice on his ankle. They’re just keeping him off feet. We’ll have a scan on that and we’ll know more about that tomorrow.
“Apart from that, there’s a few bruised and tired bodies, but I think most of them came through pretty well. Fingers crossed that Mark comes through and everyone else does tomorrow when we assess the players off the back of the game.
“Rob Russell as well, Rob came off with a hand injury. Again we’re not sure what that was. He was just struggling to get a grip and was replaced, probably as a matter of caution more than anything.
“That was one that again we’ll assess in the morning, and we’ll make sure that we get ahead of that tomorrow morning when we know a little bit more.”
Meanwhile, giving his reaction afterwards, Emerging Ireland captain Alex Kendellen spoke about how the players have gelled together quickly, and how this first performance, while far from perfect, augurs well for the rest of the tour.
“It was a good game. We talked about building connections on and off the pitch, and I think we showed glimpses of that today,” admitted the 23-year-old skipper.
“It’s good to get the win. I think we saw a few good performances out there and I really enjoyed it. There’s always going to be work-ons.
“We came together last week and we just talked about making connections on and off the pitch. We showed some good things out there. We’ll review that and we’ll get back to it for the Western Force game.
“I think there is a good group there. We’re building nicely. You look at the likes of Sam Prendergast, who is leading us around the park. It’s great to play with players like that and players from other provinces.”
Centre Harry Potter, the former Leicester Tigers back, scored two first-half tries as Western Force beat the Cheetahs 38-24 in today’s other encounter in Bloemfontein. You can watch all of Emerging Ireland’s matches on irishrugby+.
Images & Content from Irish Rugby & Images © Inpho Photography
6 Nations
Easterby Names Emerging Ireland Team To Face The Pumas
The Emerging Ireland team to face The Pumas in the opening game of the three-match Tour of South Africa on Wednesday afternoon (4pm local time/3pm Irish time) has been named.
Emerging Ireland Head Coach Simon Easterby has named an exciting line-up for the first game of the Tour and the side will be led by Alex Kendellen, one of the three former Ireland U20 captains in the squad alongside his Munster colleague Evan O’Connell and Leinster’s Gus McCarthy, who are both named on the bench.
Hugh Gavin lines up alongside Sean O’Brien in midfield, with Matthew Devine partnering out-half Sam Prendergast at half back.
Ireland Sevens Olympian Zac Ward (pictured below) is named on the left wing in a pacy-looking back three alongside Rob Russell and Ben O’Connor who starts at full-back.
In the pack, Mark Donnelly starts at loosehead prop in a front row which includes hooker Stephen Smyth and tighthead prop Jack Aungier.
Harry Sheridan and Darragh Murray are named at second row, with Kendellen joined by Cormac Izuchukwu and James Culhane in the back row.
Ulster duo Jack Murphy and Jude Postlethwaite are named amongst the replacements bench which includes 19-year-old loosehead prop Alex Usanov, Connacht’s Sean Jansen and prop Ronan Foxe, while Ethan Coughlan provides scrum-half cover.
Looking ahead to the game at Toyota Stadium, Easterby said: “The Pumas will present a real test, coming as it does in the first of three games in seven days. They’re a physical team who have come off a competitive Currie Cup campaign.
“The three games will ask different questions of the group and that is exactly the kind of environment we want to foster and to see how the players react to a pressurised and competitive environment. We had a good pitch session on Monday afternoon and the players are itching to get out there.
“We will be managing our resources given the close proximity of the games and it’s a younger and less experienced group than the one that competed two years ago. But the talent, energy and enthusiasm of this group has been obvious over the course of the last six days. We’re delighted to be here in Bloemfontein and the squad is ready to get going.”
The three-match Series will be shown live on SuperSport and will be available on IrishRugby+ here.
Emerging Ireland:
15. Ben O’Connor (UCC RFC/Munster)
14. Rob Russell (Dublin University FC/Leinster)
13. Sean O’Brien (Clontarf FC/Munster)
12. Hugh Gavin (Galwegians RFC/Connacht)
11. Zac Ward (Ballynahinch RFC/Ulster/Ireland Sevens)
10. Sam Prendergast (Lansdowne FC/Leinster)
9. Matthew Devine (Corinthians RFC/Connacht)
1. Mark Donnelly (Cork Constitution FC/Munster)
2. Stephen Smyth (Old Wesley RFC/Leinster)
3. Jack Aungier (Clontarf FC/Connacht)
4. Harry Sheridan (Dublin University FC/Ulster)
5. Darragh Murray (Buccaneers RFC/Connacht)
6. Cormac Izuchukwu (Ballynahinch RFC/Ulster)
7. Alex Kendellen (UCC RFC/Munster)(captain)
8. James Culhane (UCD RFC/Leinster)
Replacements:
16. Gus McCarthy (UCD RFC/Leinster)
17. Alex Usanov (Clontarf FC/Leinster)
18. Ronan Foxe (Garryowen FC/Munster)
19. Evan O’Connell (UL Bohemian RFC/Munster)
20. Sean Jansen (Connacht)
21. Ethan Coughlan (Shannon RFC/Munster)
22. Jack Murphy (Clontarf FC/Ulster)
23. Jude Postlethwaite (City of Armagh RFC/Ulster).
Images & Content from Irish Rugby & Images © Inpho Photography
6 Nations
Emerging Ireland Update As Mullins, Donnelly & Tector Added To Squad
There are a number of changes to the Emerging Ireland squad for the upcoming tour to South Africa following the first round of the BKT United Rugby Championship last weekend.
Shayne Bolton, Jack Boyle and Tommy O’Brien are unavailable and will be replaced by Ireland Sevens back and recent Olympian Chay Mullins, Munster prop Mark Donnelly and Leinster’s Charlie Tector respectively.
The squad will convene on Wednesday morning in the IRFU High Performance Centre before travelling to South Africa on Saturday.
Emerging Ireland Squad (South Africa Tour 2024)
Forwards (18):
Jack Aungier (Clontarf FC/Connacht)
James Culhane (UCD RFC/Leinster)
Mark Donnelly (Garryowen FC/Munster)
Jordan Duggan (Naas RFC/Connacht)
Sean Edogbo (UCC RFC/Munster)
Ronan Foxe (Garryowen FC/Munster)
Cormac Izuchukwu (Ballynahinch RFC/Ulster)
Sean Jansen (Connacht)
Alex Kendellen (UCC RFC/Munster)(captain)
Gus McCarthy (UCD RFC/Leinster)
Darragh Murray (Buccaneers RFC/Connacht)
Evan O’Connell (UL Bohemian RFC/Munster)
Conor O’Tighearnaigh (UCD RFC/Leinster)
Danny Sheahan (Cork Constitution FC/Munster)
Harry Sheridan (Dublin University FC/Ulster)
Stephen Smyth (Old Wesley RFC/Leinster)
Alex Soroka (Clontarf FC/Leinster)
Scott Wilson (Queen’s University Belfast RFC/Ulster)
Backs (15):
Hugh Cooney (Clontarf FC/Leinster)
Ethan Coughlan (Shannon RFC/Munster)
Matthew Devine (Corinthians RFC/Connacht)
Cormac Foley (Lansdowne FC/Leinster)
Hugh Gavin (Galwegians RFC/Connacht)
Chay Mullins (Connacht/Ireland Sevens)
Jack Murphy (Clontarf FC/Ulster)
Sean O’Brien (Clontarf FC/Munster)
Ben O’Connor (UCC RFC/Munster)
Andrew Osborne (Naas RFC/Leinster)
Jude Postlethwaite (City of Armagh RFC/Ulster)
Sam Prendergast (Lansdowne FC/Leinster)
Rob Russell (Dublin University FC/Leinster)
Charlie Tector (Lansdowne FC/Leinster)
Zac Ward (Ballynahinch RFC/Ulster/Ireland Sevens).
Emerging Ireland Tour Fixtures
• Wednesday, 2 October: Emerging Ireland v The Pumas, 4pm local time/3pm Irish time
• Sunday, 6 October: Emerging Ireland v Western Force, 1pm local time/12pm Irish time
• Wednesday, 9 October: Emerging Ireland v The Cheetahs, 7pm local time/6pm Irish time
Images & Content from Irish Rugby & Images © Inpho Photography
-
Premiership1 week ago
Connacht v Sharks Team Announcement
-
URC1 week ago
Cardiff make two changes for Welsh derby clash
-
URC1 week ago
Ulster ready for Emirates Lions in Johannesburg
-
Premiership1 week ago
Team News: Chiefs Change Matchday 23 for Trip to Reigning Champions
-
Premiership1 week ago
TEAM NEWS | Sale Sharks v Saracens
-
URC1 week ago
Gavin Coombes Set For 100th Munster Appearance
-
6 Nations6 days ago
Easterby Names Emerging Ireland Team To Face The Pumas
-
Premiership4 days ago
TEAM NEWS | Sale Sharks v Gloucester